|
System Selection
There are a number of variations
of all air systems available to the designer. Deciding which system to
employ is not always an easy task and requires careful consultation between
the designer and the owner. Before making such a decision, consideration
of the performance, capacity and reliability aspects of the desired system
must be weighed against the cost (installed and operating) and spatial
limitations of the project. The following paragraphs identify some of
the more critical determinations that guide most system selections.
Building Use
The intended use of the structure
is also a major determinant in the selection of a system. For example,
office buildings where there is a daily operational schedule often employ
fan powered terminals with auxiliary heating coils serving their perimeter
zones. These terminals allow the central system to be turned off or �set-back�
during times the building is unoccupied. The fan terminal can maintain
minimal heating requirements during these periods by cycling its integral
fan and heating coil.
Contamination Constraints
Many times the intended use of
a building creates special constraints that must be considered in the
selection of the system components. Hospitals and other medical facilities
generally discourage the use of hot water reheat coils on terminals serving
patient areas as the coil may harbor bacterial growth. Double duct systems
are often employed in these areas as they eliminate the need for such
coils. In addition, operating and clean room areas usually require constant
volume (dual duct) systems with internal insulation liners to maintain
required ventilation and contaminant control (pressurization) rates.
|
|

Acoustical Constraints
Other facilities such as broadcast
studios, theatres, and libraries require very low noise levels. Equipment
must be selected (and located) to comply with these constraints. Single
duct (with/without reheat) terminals are generally used in these applications.
Fan powered terminals are usually not considered for such applications
due to their intrinsically higher radiated noise levels.
Maintenance / Accessibility
Considerations
Finally, certain building types
require an inordinately high level of reliability of the terminal unit
components due to the difficulty and costs associated with performing
preventative maintenance and repairs on the equipment. For example, the
cost of gaining access to a terminal unit mounted above a clean room may
be prohibited if the space must then be disinfected and re-qualified.
When such costs are likely, the selection of a simple, low maintenance
terminal such as a mechanical type is prudent. Problems such as this may
also be avoided by locating the terminal such that access through the
clean room is not required.
|
Building Size
The selection of the central system
air handler greatly influences the type of terminal units that are employed.
Large buildings often consist of many zones and require significant amounts
of air to condition and ventilate these spaces. Central system air handlers
are generally employed which are then ducted to the various zones. Interior
zones, which tend to be somewhat uniform in their cooling demands (and require
little or no heat), are generally serviced by single duct VAV terminals.
Perimeter zones whose cooling and heating loads vary significantly are often
serviced by either constant or variable volume fan terminals with auxiliary
reheat coils. |
|
In very small building or low-rise
buildings which are occupied by numerous tenants (such as shopping malls),
small package air conditioning equipment may be employed. Many times this
equipment requires that constant airflow delivery be maintained. In this
case, low pressure bypass terminals are often employed. |
|
Environmental Factors
Key to the selection of a system
is the environment in which it is installed. The environment consists
not only of the physical environment but also the operational and legal
environment. Certain legislated requirements, such as ventilation requirements
and local building codes may affect the system selection. For example,
reheat coils may be required for use (with single duct VAV terminals)
in interior zones when significant ventilation rates must be maintained,
as the minimum air flow into the space must be reheated to prevent overcooling
during periods of minimum demand. Local building codes may discourage
the use of certain types of terminals (such as fan powered) when they
prescribe major protective treatment be employed for compliance.
|
|
System selection is
directly influenced by the physical environment. The variation in cooling
and heating loads of the zone served by a terminal largely determines its
type. Fan powered terminals are ideal for zones (such as outside offices)
where loads vary greatly, either by season, solar load, or occupancy. Single
duct terminals (or constant volume fan terminals) are generally employed
where significant variations in load are not expected. |
Cost Factors
Finally, a clear analysis of expected
costs should be prepared prior to system selection. These costs should include
installed costs, operation costs, and maintenance costs. The relative importance
of these costs may affect the system selection itself. For example, installation
and maintenance costs could be more important to a developer/owner (where
tenants are billed for utilities) while operational costs might drive equipment
selection for an owner occupied structure. Variable volume terminals (single
duct or fan powered) with electric heat might offer lower installed costs,
while these terminals with hot water reheat might offer lower operational
costs. This might be reversed in areas where electricity costs are lower
in relation to gas or fuel oil costs (for running boilers for hot water
generation). |
|
|